Looking for the Buffalo Cafe menu and current prices? We have compiled a comprehensive list of all their menu items and pricing details for August 2026. Across 16 different categories, they offer a diverse selection of 73 items including various main entrees as well as mouthwatering desserts. Check out the updated tables below to plan your budget before you visit.
- Lowest Price Item: Soup Of The Day ($5.00)
- Highest Price Item: Bison Meatloaf ($21.00)
- Average Item Price: $13.75
📞 Buffalo Cafe Contact Info & Operating Hours
About Buffalo Cafe
Buffalo Cafe is a popular hybrid restaurant and cafe establishment known for its selection of Lunch Sandwiches & More, Craft Burgers and Old Fashion Milk Shakes. The prices listed in this guide are gathered from official menus and public sources, updated for August 2026.
📋 Menu Highlights & Variety
Looking closely at the menu architecture, the most variety is found in the Lunch Sandwiches & More section. This category includes 9 unique items, providing customers with many options. The remaining 16 sections offer additional variety to round out your dining experience.
🔍 Detailed Menu Category Analysis
📌 Morning Classics Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Morning Classics section, Buffalo Cafe offers 5 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Two Eggs & Toast” priced at $6.00. The most expensive choice is the “Biscuit & Gravy Combo” costing $14.00, with an average category price of $11.20. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Morning Classics
- The Two Eggs & Toast, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $6.00.
- The Avocado Toast, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $11.00.
- The Biscuit & Gravy Combo, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a generous double or large portion, for $14.00.
📌 Brioche French Toast Menu and Price Analysis
The Buffalo Cafe Brioche French Toast menu features 3 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Granny's French Toast Combo” for $11.00, while the highest is the “The Stumptown Special” at $14.00. Overall, items in this section average around $12.67. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Brioche French Toast
- The Granny's French Toast Combo, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a generous double or large portion, for $11.00.
- The Nicole's French Toast, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $13.00.
- The The Stumptown Special, which highlights a special recipe, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $14.00.
📌 Buttermilk Pancakes Menu and Price Analysis
The Buffalo Cafe Buttermilk Pancakes menu features 3 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Short Stack” for $9.00, while the highest is the “McCabe's Combo” at $14.00. Overall, items in this section average around $12.00. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Buttermilk Pancakes
- The Short Stack, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $9.00.
- The Mully's Combo, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a generous double or large portion, for $13.00.
- The McCabe's Combo, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a generous double or large portion, for $14.00.
📌 Big Sky Benedicts Menu and Price Analysis
Under the Big Sky Benedicts section, Buffalo Cafe lists 2 different options. The most economical item is the “Traditional Eggs Benedict” at $14.00, while the more premium “Bacon & Avocado Benedict” is offered at $16.00, with a category average price of $15.00.
📌 Farm Fresh Scrambles & Omelets Menu and Price Analysis
In the Farm Fresh Scrambles & Omelets category at Buffalo Cafe, there are 5 available items. Pricing starts from $14.00 for the “Higgins Scramble” and goes up to $15.00 for the “Joe's Omelet”. The mean price for this section is $14.20. These options represent a well-balanced range to accommodate different preferences.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Farm Fresh Scrambles & Omelets
- The Higgins Scramble, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $14.00.
- The Joe's Omelet, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $15.00.
📌 The Buffalo Pies Menu and Price Analysis
The Buffalo Cafe The Buffalo Pies menu features 6 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “The Original” for $14.00, while the highest is the “Morning Glory” at $15.00. Overall, items in this section average around $14.17. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in The Buffalo Pies
- The The Original, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $14.00.
- The Morning Glory, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $15.00.
📌 Whitefish Huevos Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Whitefish Huevos section, Buffalo Cafe offers 3 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Huevos Ranchero” priced at $13.00. The most expensive choice is the “Chorizo Breakfast Burrito” costing $15.00, with an average category price of $14.33. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Whitefish Huevos
- The Huevos Ranchero, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $13.00.
- The Dow's Huevos, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $15.00.
- The Chorizo Breakfast Burrito, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $15.00.
📌 Old Fashion Milk Shakes Menu and Price Analysis
The Buffalo Cafe Old Fashion Milk Shakes menu features 8 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Wild Huckleberry” for $8.00, while the highest is the “Combo 2 Flavors” at $9.00. Overall, items in this section average around $8.13. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Old Fashion Milk Shakes
- The Wild Huckleberry, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $8.00.
- The Combo 2 Flavors, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a generous double or large portion, for $9.00.
📌 Lunch Sandwiches & More Menu and Price Analysis
In the Lunch Sandwiches & More category at Buffalo Cafe, there are 8 available items. Pricing starts from $13.00 for the “The Reuben” and goes up to $15.00 for the “Chicken & Avocado Sandwich”. The mean price for this section is $14.25. These options represent a well-balanced range to accommodate different preferences.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Lunch Sandwiches & More
- The The Reuben, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $13.00.
- The California Club, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $14.00.
- The Chicken & Avocado Sandwich, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $15.00.
📌 Craft Burgers Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Craft Burgers section, Buffalo Cafe offers 9 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Classic Cheese Burger” priced at $14.00. The most expensive choice is the “Hot Date” costing $17.00, with an average category price of $15.67. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Craft Burgers
- The Classic Cheese Burger, which highlights a special recipe, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $14.00, (contains dairy).
- The Chef's Burger Of The Week, which highlights a special recipe, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $16.00.
- The Hot Date, which highlights a spicy flavor, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $17.00.
📌 Lunch Salads & Soup Menu and Price Analysis
The Buffalo Cafe Lunch Salads & Soup menu features 6 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Soup Of The Day” for $5.00, while the highest is the “Grilled Chicken Caesar” at $16.00. Overall, items in this section average around $11.67. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Lunch Salads & Soup
- The Soup Of The Day, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $5.00.
- The Soup & Salad Combo, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a generous double or large portion, for $11.00.
- The Grilled Chicken Caesar, is grilled to perfection over open fire, as a standard filling portion, for $16.00.
📌 For The Table Menu and Price Analysis
Under the For The Table section, Buffalo Cafe lists 2 different options. The most economical item is the “Parmesan Fries” at $11.00, while the more premium “Beer Battered Onion Rings” is offered at $11.00, with a category average price of $11.00.
📌 Homestyle Favorites Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Homestyle Favorites section, Buffalo Cafe offers 4 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Tutie's Mac 'N Cheese” priced at $16.00. The most expensive choice is the “Bison Meatloaf” costing $21.00, with an average category price of $19.00. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Homestyle Favorites
- The Tutie's Mac 'N Cheese, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $16.00, (contains dairy).
- The Parmesan Crusted Chicken Breast, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $19.00, (contains gluten).
- The Bison Meatloaf, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $21.00.
📌 Tacos Menu and Price Analysis
The Buffalo Cafe Tacos menu features 3 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Montana Elk Tacos (3)” for $17.00, while the highest is the “Cali-Style Braised Pork Burrito” at $18.00. Overall, items in this section average around $17.33. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Tacos
- The Montana Elk Tacos (3), is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $17.00.
- The Cali-Style Braised Pork Burrito, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $18.00.
📌 Sandwiches Menu and Price Analysis
The Buffalo Cafe Sandwiches menu features 3 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Chicken & Avocado Sandwich” for $16.00, while the highest is the “Grilled Steak Sandwich” at $19.00. Overall, items in this section average around $17.33. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Sandwiches
- The Chicken & Avocado Sandwich, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $16.00.
- The Honey-Hot Crispy Chicken Sandwich, which highlights a spicy flavor and sweet notes, is deep-fried for a satisfying crispy texture, as a standard filling portion, for $17.00.
- The menu features the classic Grilled Steak Sandwich, priced at $19.00.
📌 Dinner Salads Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Dinner Salads section, Buffalo Cafe offers 3 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “The Hot Veggie Salad” priced at $16.00. The most expensive choice is the “NY Steak Salad” costing $19.00, with an average category price of $17.67. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Dinner Salads
- The The Hot Veggie Salad, which highlights a spicy flavor, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $16.00.
- The Blackened Shrimp Caesar, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $18.00.
- The menu features the classic NY Steak Salad, priced at $19.00.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the cheapest item on the Buffalo Cafe menu?
The most budget-friendly item on the Buffalo Cafe menu is the 'Soup Of The Day', which is priced at $5.00.
What is the most expensive item on the Buffalo Cafe menu?
The most expensive item currently listed on the Buffalo Cafe menu is the 'Bison Meatloaf', with a price of $21.00.
What is the average price of menu items at Buffalo Cafe?
Considering all categories, the average price of a single portion at Buffalo Cafe is approximately $13.75.
What are the main menu categories at Buffalo Cafe?
The main categories on the Buffalo Cafe menu include Morning Classics, Brioche French Toast, Buttermilk Pancakes, Big Sky Benedicts, offering a wide variety of choices.