Plan your next meal with the official Old Post Office Bagel Shop menu and pricing updated for August 2026. Featuring 7 menu sections and a total of 30 items, there is something to suit every preference and budget. Review our category analysis and lists below to easily calculate the cost of your favorite combinations.
- Lowest Price Item: Cookies ($2.00)
- Highest Price Item: BLT ($6.85)
- Average Item Price: $4.13
📞 Old Post Office Bagel Shop Contact Info & Operating Hours
About Old Post Office Bagel Shop
Old Post Office Bagel Shop is a popular coffee shop and cafe known for its selection of Breakfast Sandwiches, Bagels and Desserts. The prices listed in this guide are gathered from official menus and public sources, updated for August 2026.
📋 Menu Highlights & Variety
Looking closely at the menu architecture, the most variety is found in the Breakfast Sandwiches section. This category includes 8 unique items, providing customers with many options. The remaining 6 sections offer additional variety to round out your dining experience.
🔍 Detailed Menu Category Analysis
📌 Bagels Menu and Price Analysis
In the Bagels category at Old Post Office Bagel Shop, there are 6 available items. Pricing starts from $2.80 for the “Bagel With Butter Or Jam” and goes up to $6.25 for the “Bagel With Goat Cheese”. The mean price for this section is $4.17. These options represent a well-balanced range to accommodate different preferences.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Bagels
- The Bagel With Butter Or Jam, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $2.80, (contains dairy).
- The Bagel With Flavored Cream, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $3.95, (contains dairy).
- The Bagel With Goat Cheese, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $6.25, (contains dairy).
📌 Spreads Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Spreads section, Old Post Office Bagel Shop offers 3 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Cream Cheese” priced at $4.85. The most expensive choice is the “Brown Hummus” costing $6.50, with an average category price of $5.62. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Spreads
- The Cream Cheese, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $4.85, (contains dairy).
- The Flavored Cream Cheese, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $5.50, (contains dairy).
- The Brown Hummus, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $6.50.
📌 Baked Goods Menu and Price Analysis
The Old Post Office Bagel Shop Baked Goods menu features 3 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Scones” for $3.00, while the highest is the “Muffins” at $3.60. Overall, items in this section average around $3.20. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Baked Goods
- The Scones, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $3.00.
- The Muffins, is freshly baked or chilled, as a standard filling portion, for $3.60.
📌 Desserts Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Desserts section, Old Post Office Bagel Shop offers 5 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Cookies” priced at $2.00. The most expensive choice is the “Brownies” costing $3.85, with an average category price of $2.86. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Desserts
- The Cookies, is freshly baked or chilled, as a standard filling portion, for $2.00.
- The Bars, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $2.95.
- The Brownies, is freshly baked or chilled, as a standard filling portion, for $3.85.
📌 Beverages Menu and Price Analysis
The Old Post Office Bagel Shop Beverages menu features 6 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Hot Tea” for $2.00, while the highest is the “Mocha” at $3.50. Overall, items in this section average around $2.71. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Beverages
- The menu features the classic Hot Tea, priced at $2.00.
- The menu features the classic Hot Chocolate, priced at $2.70.
- The Mocha, is made to order according to recipe, in a standard cup size, for $3.50.
📌 Breakfast Sandwiches Menu and Price Analysis
The Old Post Office Bagel Shop Breakfast Sandwiches menu features 7 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Bagel With Fried Egg” for $3.15, while the highest is the “BLT” at $6.85. Overall, items in this section average around $5.99. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Breakfast Sandwiches
- The Bagel With Fried Egg, is deep-fried for a satisfying crispy texture, as a standard filling portion, for $3.15.
- The Egg And Cheese With Ham, Bacon Or Sausage, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $6.85, (contains dairy).
- The BLT, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $6.85.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the cheapest item on the Old Post Office Bagel Shop menu?
The most budget-friendly item on the Old Post Office Bagel Shop menu is the 'Cookies', which is priced at $2.00.
What is the most expensive item on the Old Post Office Bagel Shop menu?
The most expensive item currently listed on the Old Post Office Bagel Shop menu is the 'BLT', with a price of $6.85.
What is the average price of menu items at Old Post Office Bagel Shop?
Considering all categories, the average price of a single portion at Old Post Office Bagel Shop is approximately $4.13.
What are the main menu categories at Old Post Office Bagel Shop?
The main categories on the Old Post Office Bagel Shop menu include Bagels, Spreads, Eggs, Baked Goods, offering a wide variety of choices.