The updated Pumpernickel's Deli menu list has been organized here with the latest pricing details for August 2026. With a breakdown of 17 categories, you can find prices for delicious main course choices, appetizers, sweet treats and hot and cold drinks and make an informed ordering decision. Below you will find the complete item tables and statistics to help you choose the best options.
- Lowest Price Item: Cheese ($0.70)
- Highest Price Item: Salad Plate ($16.99)
- Average Item Price: $9.97
📞 Pumpernickel's Deli Contact Info & Operating Hours
About Pumpernickel's Deli
Pumpernickel's Deli is a popular restaurant known for its selection of Sandwiches, Paninis and Starters. The prices listed in this guide are gathered from official menus and public sources, updated for August 2026.
📋 Menu Highlights & Variety
The category with the greatest selection is Sandwiches, offering 19 choices. Customers looking for variety will find plenty of delicious options here alongside the other 14 categories.
🔍 Detailed Menu Category Analysis
📌 Starters Menu and Price Analysis
The Pumpernickel's Deli Starters menu features 13 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Basket Of French Fries” for $4.99, while the highest is the “Meatball Platter” at $15.99. Overall, items in this section average around $8.80. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Starters
- The Basket Of French Fries, is tossed with premium dressings and toppings, as a standard filling portion, for $4.99.
- The Mozzarella Sticks, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $8.49, (contains dairy).
- The Meatball Platter, is made to order according to recipe, in a standard cup size, for $15.99.
📌 Cold Crisp Salads Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Cold Crisp Salads section, Pumpernickel's Deli offers 13 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Add Grilled Chicken” priced at $2.99. The most expensive choice is the “Salad Plate” costing $16.99, with an average category price of $10.73. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Cold Crisp Salads
- The Add Grilled Chicken, is grilled to perfection over open fire, as a standard filling portion, for $2.99.
- The Chicken Caesar Salad, is tossed with premium dressings and toppings, as a standard filling portion, for $12.99.
- The Salad Plate, is tossed with premium dressings and toppings, as a standard filling portion, for $16.99.
📌 Sandwiches Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Sandwiches section, Pumpernickel's Deli offers 19 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Macy's Pepper & Egg” priced at $8.79. The most expensive choice is the “Madison Ave. Steak Sandwich” costing $13.79, with an average category price of $11.96. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Sandwiches
- The Macy's Pepper & Egg, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $8.79.
- The Italian Hoagie, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $11.99.
- The menu features the classic Madison Ave. Steak Sandwich, priced at $13.79.
📌 Paninis Menu and Price Analysis
In the Paninis category at Pumpernickel's Deli, there are 16 available items. Pricing starts from $11.79 for the “Chicken Club Panini” and goes up to $13.99 for the “Madison Ave. Steak Panini”. The mean price for this section is $12.52. These options represent a well-balanced range to accommodate different preferences.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Paninis
- The Chicken Club Panini, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $11.79.
- The Chicken Pesto Panini, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $12.49.
- The menu features the classic Madison Ave. Steak Panini, priced at $13.99.
📌 Wraps Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Wraps section, Pumpernickel's Deli offers 13 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Turkey Club Wrap” priced at $10.79. The most expensive choice is the “Steak Wrap” costing $12.29, with an average category price of $11.24. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Wraps
- The Turkey Club Wrap, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $10.79.
- The Buffalo Chicken Wrap, which highlights a spicy flavor, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $11.29.
- The menu features the classic Steak Wrap, priced at $12.29.
📌 Sandwich Extras Menu and Price Analysis
The Pumpernickel's Deli Sandwich Extras menu features 7 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Cheese” for $0.70, while the highest is the “Roasted Peppers” at $1.65. Overall, items in this section average around $1.36. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Sandwich Extras
- The Cheese, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $0.70, (contains dairy).
- The Sweet Fried Peppers, which highlights a sweet notes, is freshly baked or chilled, as a standard filling portion, for $1.50.
- The Roasted Peppers, is slowly baked in the oven, as a standard filling portion, for $1.65.
📌 Homemade Soups – Made Daily Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Homemade Soups – Made Daily section, Pumpernickel's Deli offers 4 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Cup” priced at $3.79. The most expensive choice is the “Quart of Soup To Go” costing $10.99, with an average category price of $7.57. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Homemade Soups – Made Daily
- The Cup, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $3.79.
- The Bowl, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $4.99.
- The Quart of Soup To Go, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $10.99.
📌 Fresh Ground New York Burgers Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Fresh Ground New York Burgers section, Pumpernickel's Deli offers 13 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “New York Burger” priced at $11.49. The most expensive choice is the “Pork Burger” costing $13.49, with an average category price of $12.86. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Fresh Ground New York Burgers
- The New York Burger, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $11.49.
- The Bacon Cheese Burger, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $12.79, (contains dairy).
- The Pork Burger, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $13.49.
📌 Park Ave. Chicken Sandwich Specialties Menu and Price Analysis
In the Park Ave. Chicken Sandwich Specialties category at Pumpernickel's Deli, there are 6 available items. Pricing starts from $10.99 for the “Marinated Grilled Chicken Breast” and goes up to $12.79 for the “Chicken Philly”. The mean price for this section is $11.92. These options represent a well-balanced range to accommodate different preferences.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Park Ave. Chicken Sandwich Specialties
- The Marinated Grilled Chicken Breast, is grilled to perfection over open fire, as a standard filling portion, for $10.99.
- The Alpine Chicken Breast, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $11.99.
- The Chicken Philly, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $12.79.
📌 From The Grill Menu and Price Analysis
The Pumpernickel's Deli From The Grill menu features 6 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Grilled Cheese” for $5.99, while the highest is the “Grilled Cheese & Pastrami” at $11.99. Overall, items in this section average around $8.62. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in From The Grill
- The Grilled Cheese, is grilled to perfection over open fire, as a standard filling portion, for $5.99, (contains dairy).
- The Grilled Cheese, Tomato & Bacon, is grilled to perfection over open fire, as a standard filling portion, for $7.79, (contains dairy).
- The Grilled Cheese & Pastrami, is grilled to perfection over open fire, as a standard filling portion, for $11.99, (contains dairy).
📌 Croissants Menu and Price Analysis
The Pumpernickel's Deli Croissants menu features 6 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Tuna Salad & Swiss Cheese” for $11.49, while the highest is the “South Street Seaport” at $11.99. Overall, items in this section average around $11.87. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Croissants
- The Tuna Salad & Swiss Cheese, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $11.49, (contains dairy).
- The Chicken Salad & Swiss Cheese, is tossed with premium dressings and toppings, as a standard filling portion, for $11.79, (contains dairy).
- The South Street Seaport, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $11.99.
📌 Triple Decker Sandwiches Menu and Price Analysis
The Pumpernickel's Deli Triple Decker Sandwiches menu features 7 different items. The lowest priced choice is the “Grand Central Club” for $12.49, while the highest is the “Madison Square” at $15.99. Overall, items in this section average around $14.75. You can compare the complete breakdown of items in the table below.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Triple Decker Sandwiches
- The Grand Central Club, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $12.49.
- The Little Italy, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $13.99.
- The Madison Square, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $15.99.
📌 Kids' Menu Menu and Price Analysis
For those ordering from the Kids' Menu section, Pumpernickel's Deli offers 4 selections. A budget-friendly option is the “Grilled Cheese & Fries” priced at $6.29. The most expensive choice is the “Burger & Fries” costing $6.29, with an average category price of $6.29. Check out the detailed price table below to choose your favorite dishes.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Kids' Menu
- The Grilled Cheese & Fries, is grilled to perfection over open fire, as a standard filling portion, for $6.29, (contains dairy).
- The Burger & Fries, is cooked fresh in the kitchen, as a standard filling portion, for $6.29.
📌 Beverages Menu and Price Analysis
In the Beverages category at Pumpernickel's Deli, there are 12 available items. Pricing starts from $1.59 for the “Soda Water” and goes up to $2.95 for the “Chocolate Milk”. The mean price for this section is $2.41. These options represent a well-balanced range to accommodate different preferences.
⭐ Highlighted Item Reviews in Beverages
- The menu features the classic Soda Water, priced at $1.59.
- The Coffee, is made to order according to recipe, in a standard cup size, for $2.49.
- The menu features the classic Chocolate Milk, priced at $2.95.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the cheapest item on the Pumpernickel's Deli menu?
The most budget-friendly item on the Pumpernickel's Deli menu is the 'Cheese', which is priced at $0.70.
What is the most expensive item on the Pumpernickel's Deli menu?
The most expensive item currently listed on the Pumpernickel's Deli menu is the 'Salad Plate', with a price of $16.99.
What is the average price of menu items at Pumpernickel's Deli?
Considering all categories, the average price of a single portion at Pumpernickel's Deli is approximately $9.97.
What are the main menu categories at Pumpernickel's Deli?
The main categories on the Pumpernickel's Deli menu include Starters, Cold Crisp Salads, Overstuffed Sandwiches, Sandwiches, offering a wide variety of choices.